It is not known what the Commodore's Trophy is awarded for. There is a list of engraved names 2000 - 2004 on a plate on one side of the base. It looks like (i.e. glue residue) there were plates on the back and other side which have been lost.
Here are some photographs of past winners
There are no images in the gallery.
| Year | Held by | Note |
| 2023 | With Martin Egan | |
| 2015 | At Matt Grayson's house | |
| 2013 | ||
| 2004 | Tim Smith | |
| 2003 | Nikki Birrell | |
| 2002 | Johnny McGovern | |
| 2001 | Stuart Bithell | |
| 2000 | Toby Heppell |
